Thursday, January 30, 2025

Celebrating 30 Years of Clubcard: The Transformation of Retail Loyalty Programs

In the early 1990s, before the internet changed everything, retail loyalty programs felt outdated. Remember Green Shield stamps? Then, Tesco partnered with a small startup called Dunnhumby, and that changed the game. They took what little tech was available and built the infrastructure for the Tesco Clubcard. This wasn’t just a new loyalty card; it reshaped how businesses understood their customers.

Fast forward to February 13, 2025, when Clubcard turns 30. It’s still influential. Tesco’s CEO, Ken Murphy, recently discussed how they might use artificial intelligence to help customers make healthier shopping choices. Picture this: AI nudging you when your shopping habits slip. It might say, “Hey, you’re consuming too much sodium! Consider these alternatives.”

Dunnhumby, which was relatively unknown back then, propelled Tesco ahead of its competitors, like Sainsbury’s. The founders, Edwina Dunn and Clive Humby, had worked at CACI on geographic targeting. They realized that by merging CACI’s Acorn data with customer information from stores, they could uncover valuable insights about consumer behavior.

Dunn says the breakthrough came when they considered what could be achieved with real customer data instead of stale census information. It was a hard sell initially. Simon Hay, a former CEO of Dunnhumby, recounts how they pushed the limits of available technology. Back then, data storage was pricey, and most businesses discarded data they thought was useless.

As Dunnhumby experimented with early clients, including Booker Cash & Carry and Mercury Communications, Tesco began testing its Clubcard in a few locations. Initially skeptical, Tesco changed course after one of its marketers heard Humby speak at a conference about big data analysis. Soon after, they started sharing Clubcard data with Dunnhumby to see what they could uncover.

By 1994, they analyzed that customers responded positively to discounts and promotions, and when they presented these findings to Tesco executives, they were met with surprise. Lord MacLaurin, the chairman, famously remarked that Dunnhumby knew more about his customers after just a few months than he did after 30 years in business.

The momentum took off. Before Clubcard launched on February 13, 1995, Tesco printed 16 million cards, closed stores for a weekend to prepare, and rolled out a massive advertising campaign. In its first year, Tesco overtook Sainsbury’s, and within three years, Clubcard helped double its market share.

In those early days, they worked with only a fraction of the data. Analyzing a single store required a 10% sample, and they could only pull insights on broader categories, not specific brands. Dunn recalls how they quickly leveraged the modest insights they gathered, forging a path forward.

By 1997, Clubcard’s vouchers became highly personalized. Customers fell into various segments, and that allowed them to send tailored promotions. Major brands engaged too, but there were many battles, like when Coke wanted to lure Pepsi drinkers. Dunnhumby insisted they could only promote to their existing customers, showcasing the competitive nature of those relationships.

The data didn’t just support marketing; it informed strategic decisions across the entire business. Insights led to the launch of the Finest product range, which today brings in around £2 billion annually. Data analysis also guided store locations and the creation of Tesco Bank and online shopping.

In 2001, Tesco bought a majority stake in Dunnhumby, increasing it to 84% by 2006. This shift changed the dynamic, making it tougher for Dunnhumby to disrupt the industry. They chose to expand internationally, focusing on CPGs and developing an analytics platform called The Shop, allowing clients to analyze customer data with privacy protections.

As technology improved, Dunnhumby began processing more data. They could now churn out reports daily instead of weekly, transforming their analysis capabilities and providing deeper insights into market dynamics.

After the co-founders stepped back in 2011, Hay took the reins but acknowledged that disruption became harder under Tesco’s ownership. Dunn still believes that while Dunnhumby’s edge may be dulled, the potential remains high, especially as AI plays a bigger role in retail.

Dunn emphasizes that Tesco’s wealth of customer data likely places it ahead in the AI race. Despite the extensive work done in the past three decades, many companies still struggle with poor-quality datasets, limiting their ability to harness AI effectively. The landscape remains ripe for innovation, with Dunnhumby and Clubcard keeping Tesco in the spotlight of data-driven retail.